TEA: SCIENCE SHOWS EGW WRONG Log Out | Topics | Search
Moderators | Edit Profile

Former Adventist Fellowship Forum » ARCHIVED DISCUSSIONS 1 » TEA: SCIENCE SHOWS EGW WRONG « Previous Next »

Author Message
Max
Posted on Tuesday, December 05, 2000 - 3:04 am:   Edit PostDelete PostPrint Post   Move Post (Moderator/Admin Only)

SCIENCE SHOWS ELLEN WHITE ALSO
WRONG ABOUT TEA, ESPECIALLY GREEN
TEA

Kam S. Woo, M.D., professor and consultant
cardiologist at the Chinese University of Hong
Kong says people should recognize the
protective effects of a traditional Chinese diet,
including GREEN TEA.

Woo believes it is no coincidence that
Guangdong Province in southern China has
one of the lowest rates of heart disease in the
world.

One reason: Their diet includes tofu and
GREEN TEA. Researchers are not sure how
GREEN TEA might protect against heart
disease, but good research studies show that
it does.

Dr. Woo says the protective effect may have
something to do with the antioxidants in the
beverage. Antioxidants, which are found in
vitamins and foods, are thought to fight heart
disease by counteracting oxygen free-radicals.
Oxygen free-radicals are unstable molecules
that can combine with cholesterol to form
oxidized cholesterol. In this form, cholesterol
is more likely to collect on the blood vessels,
forming fatty deposits that lead to heart attacks
and strokes.

The combined thickness of the intima (lining)
and media (middle muscle) layers of the
carotid artery are considered a good indicator
of heart disease. In healthy adults 65 or older,
increased thickness correlates with a higher
risk of heart attack and stroke, while in
younger adults, with no symptoms of heart
disease, thicker intima-media reflects the
probable development of atherosclerosis.

Dr. Woo says other research is planned to
look at such questions as whether GREEN
TEA is more protective than BLACK TEA. "Our
collaborative project will provide a unique
opportunity to identify adverse and protective
dietary and lifestyle factors, and the underlying
mechanisms that may predispose
westernized Chinese to heart disease," Dr.
Woo says. "It will also contribute an overall
better understanding of how we might use
dietary means to help prevent heart disease in
Westernized Chinese and Americans."

From information provided by the American
Heart Association available at:

http://www.americanheart.org/Whats_News/A
HA_News_Releases/11-10-99_6-comment.ht
ml

**************
Note from Max: Three things to keep in mind.

1. Green tea and black tea are both tea, and
both come from the same plant. The
difference is only in how the brew is prepared.

2. "Herb teas" -- such as pepperment,
sassafrass, comfrey, etc. -- do not come from
the tea plant at all. These are more
scientifically called "botanical infusions," not
teas.

3. While EGW probably only wrote against
black tea -- she said drinking it was a sin --
black tea has also been shown scientifically to
have considerable health benefits, though, as
with green tea, the scientific community hasn't
yet isolated the exact reasons for the health
benefits.
Denisegilmore
Posted on Tuesday, December 05, 2000 - 11:43 am:   Edit PostDelete PostPrint Post   Move Post (Moderator/Admin Only)

Max,
Are you implying that 'the drink from China' is not a sin?? :)) Must I pull up sister Ellen's words for you? You are falling Max and I fear for you!! <wink, wink>..:::chuckling away over here:::
God Bless,
Denise
Max
Posted on Tuesday, December 05, 2000 - 12:00 pm:   Edit PostDelete PostPrint Post   Move Post (Moderator/Admin Only)

"Be angry and sin not," says Scripture. And I
do have a healthy anger (and praise God for
it), but not at Ellen G. White.

I see her as more a victim than a victimizer.
And I see her scolding at other people for
eating too much, for example, while she
herself was obese, as more of the same old
"denial and projection" that tends to afflict all of
us.

My anger derives more from the SDA
health-care community that has tended to
become more and more "schizophrenic"
(metaphorical sense) and hypocritical (literal
sense).

Tea, particularly green tea, is a most excellent
example. These people who know better
continue to back Ellen G. White's pathetic
ignorance and false prophecy (prophecy
means "speaking for God," not "predicting the
future").

At any rate, I thank God for truly honest souls
like you, Denise.

Max of the Cross
Denisegilmore
Posted on Tuesday, December 05, 2000 - 12:23 pm:   Edit PostDelete PostPrint Post   Move Post (Moderator/Admin Only)

Max,
Being angry at the hypocrisy is a good thing. At least I believe that. I too, have encountered, time after time, people who uphold Ellen White and all the while, they know better as they tell me so in private. I cannot understand it other than it is lack of courage on their part to speak out. Not that I'm all that courageous myself sometimes, BUT, to forever remain silent as to truth on such matters is downright lying!
As you do, I too feel sorry for Ellen White. Having read so much of her writings, I can see that she truly believed what she taught. The thing that gets me, is that there are many who have no damage to their brain and they KNOW that some of what she taught is not so. Yet, they persist and insist that it continue to be expounded upon, drilling alot of guilt into so many of people. This is what angers me. When I see children growing up with guilty consciences over so many things, I am the most irrate person they could encounter. While I give credit to Ellen White for doing what she believed in with all of her heart (for the most part), I cannot give credit to the leaders for teaching the same things and knowing full well that they are untrue. Those are the ones I spy out and verbally spar with. Someplace, somewhere, it has to be stopped. The lies need to be silenced. The guilt needs to be banished.
The Gospel of our Lord can and will take over.
God Bless you Max of the Cross,
Denise
Max
Posted on Tuesday, January 02, 2001 - 5:26 pm:   Edit PostDelete PostPrint Post   Move Post (Moderator/Admin Only)

EGW ANGEL WRONG ABOUT TEA TOO?

ìAfter water, tea is the most commonly
consumed beverage in the world,î writes Pat
Kendall, Ph.D., R.D. ìThis is good news,
because tea offers important health benefits.î

Dr. Kendall is Food Science and Human
Nutrition Specialist at Colorado State
University Cooperative Extension

Hereís what Dr. Kendall has learned from her
studies of scientific health and medical
research:

Made from the leaf the evergreen plant
Camellia sinensis -- tea reduces your risk of
cancer. This means any tea -- green, black or
red (oolong) -- except herbal teas, none of
which comes from the Camellia sinensis
plant.

But leaves that do come from the true tea plant
Camellia sinensis contain natural chemicals
called polyphenols. They fortify your body with
health-promoting antioxidants.

ìThe degree of processing determines
whether a tea will be green, black or redî says
Dr. Kendall. ìGreen teas are the least
processed. They are simply steamed quickly
before packaging. Black and red teas are
partially dried, crushed and fermented. The
length of fermentation, which causes the
leaves to blacken, determines whether the tea
will be red or black. Regardless of the
processing method, all teas contain
polyphenols.î

What do these ìnatural wonder drugsî called
polyphenols do for you?

According to Dr. Kendall they help protect your
body cells from the something damaging
called "oxidative stress."

Oxidative stress? Does that have something
to do with the oxygen that you breath in?

Yes!

While oxygen -- which is an atom -- is vital to
life, points out Dr. Kendall, it also can be
damaging to your precious body cells.

You breathe in oxygen. From your lungs it is
carried by your bloodstream to your body cells.

There, in addition to all the good it can do,
oxygen also joins up with other atoms in the
body to form nasty stuff called free radicals.

Why call these ìfree radicalsî nasty?

Well, says Dr. Kendall, ìThese can damage
the cells in our body and have been implicated
in the slow chain reaction of damage leading
to heart disease and cancer.î

So oxygen, while being necessary and good,
can also cause trouble when it joins the ìFree
Radical Gang.î Big trouble: Heart disease and
cancer.

Iíd be willing to bet Ellen G. Whiteís angel
didnít know that!

But letís press on: So how these good guys,
the Polyphenol Posse, help? Well, you already
know their hideout -- in the leaves of real black
and red and green tea leaves. And youíre
smart enough to figure out that you can get
them down in your tummy by drinking real
black or red or green tea.

But if youíre a Seventh-day Adventist youíve got
a big problem right here: How do we know
Ellen G. Whiteís angel is wrong and Godís
angel of ìscience truly so-calledî is right?

Well, Dr. Kendall is a very nice person and an
excellent scientist and sheís right here with a
big smile to tell you the answer:

ìMany studies have demonstrated the
anti-cancer properties of polyphenols,î she
says. ìThey can stop the damage that free
radicals do to cells, neutralize enzymes
essential for tumor growth, and deactivate
cancer promoters.î

Okaaay! So they help stop the Free Radical
Gang from tearing up your bodyís tissue cells.

Perhaps, being a little more doubtful of the
veracity of Ellenís angel now, youíve decided
to trust Godís angel of ìscience truly so-calledî
just a little bit more and -- shudder -- TRY
SOME!

Donít worry. The kindly medical scientist, Dr.
Kendall, is right here to help you.

ìAlthough much remains to be learned about
the health benefits of tea,î she says, ìit is
considered a good choice for at least some of
the 6 to 8 cups or glasses of fluids
recommended daily. The best teas are those
brewed from loose leaves or tea bags of
black, green or red tea, as they have the most
antioxidant power. Allow your tea to steep for
three to five minutes to allow the maximum
amount of antioxidants to be released. Iced
teas can provide as much antioxidant power
as hot teas. Keep them covered and
refrigerated. Bottled teas often have a lower
antioxidant level because they contain mostly
water and sugar.î

Now that wasnít so bad was it? Why donít we
let our hair down now and call Dr. Kendall by
her first name, Pat. Any questions?

Yes, you, over there sitting in front of that PC
screen. Iíll repeat the question for our
onlooking lurkers: ìShould I put milk in my
tea? Will milk weaken the antioxidant effect?î

And heeeeerís Kim:

ìSome people think that milk lowers tea's
anti-oxidant power because it binds to
polyphenols and inactivates them. This has
not been proven, however, so go ahead and
add some milk if you like. You'll also increase
your calcium intake.î

Ah, so if your a woman at risk for
osteoporosis, you can get some of your
necessary daily calcium by adding milk to your
tea! Thank you, Dr. Pat! That was good.

Any other questions? Yes, you there, right in
the heart of Loma Linda, California: ìAre there
any other health benefits to drinking tea?î
Excellent question! Itís long been said that the
smartest Adventists live in Loma Linda. Dr.
Kim?

ìTea also has fluoride for strong teeth, virtually
no calories, and half the amount of caffeine
found in an equally-sized cup of coffee.î

And you, up there in Berrien Springs in the
red-brick house, almost under the shadow of
the beautiful Andrews University Pioneer
Memorial Church: ìWhat about decaf tea?î

Dr. Pat: ìWhether decaffeinated teas have the
same polyphenols, and thus the same health
benefits, as regular teas has not yet been
studied. Caffeine is a natural component of
tea leaves. It is not yet known if removing
caffeine also removes polyphenols.î

Well there you have it, dear Adventist friends.

Hereís a toast of tea to your health and
preventive medicine.
Max
Posted on Tuesday, January 02, 2001 - 6:08 pm:   Edit PostDelete PostPrint Post   Move Post (Moderator/Admin Only)

Source for above news story:
http://www.colostate.edu/depts/CoopExt/
Max
Posted on Tuesday, January 02, 2001 - 6:19 pm:   Edit PostDelete PostPrint Post   Move Post (Moderator/Admin Only)

And now hear from Sr. White:

I saw that the stewards of the Lord have no
duty to help those persons who persist in
using tobacco, TEA, and coffee.

--Ellen G. White, Testimonies, vol. 1, p. 224

I do not use tea, either GREEN or BLACK. Not
a spoonful has passed my lips for many
years, except when crossing the ocean, and
once since on this side I took it as a medicine
when I was sick and vomiting. In such
circumstances it may prove a present relief.

--Ellen G. White, Testimonies on the Case of
Elder E.P. Daniels, p. 53

Why would Ellen's angel tell her to urge
shunning of SDA ministers who drank tea? Is
this evidence that she was prevaricating? Or
that her angel was mis-informed? And if
mis-informed, why mis-informed? Not from
God? And if not from God, then from where?
Or from whom? Furthermore, if wrong about
tea, then wrong about the investigative
judgment? Wrong about Christ not sitting
down at the right hand of the Father and
making atonement for sin then and there?
Two-thousand years ago? Not waiting till
1844?

Questions for the honest in heart to ask?

Max of the Cross
Valm
Posted on Tuesday, January 02, 2001 - 7:28 pm:   Edit PostDelete PostPrint Post   Move Post (Moderator/Admin Only)

Max, That was a creative and entertaining presentation. Have you thought of advertising? You have just convinced me to get out the pot and brew some tea.

Valerie
Max
Posted on Thursday, January 04, 2001 - 12:38 am:   Edit PostDelete PostPrint Post   Move Post (Moderator/Admin Only)

Healing News: ELLENíS ANGEL WRONG!
TEA HEALTHFUL: Numerous studies prove
both black and green teas to have medical
benefits

BOTH BLACK AND GREEN TEAS FIGHT
CANCER IN EARLY STAGES

Numerous studies have shown BOTH BLACK
AND GREEN TEAS to HAVE MEDICAL
BENEFITS. But that's not surprising, some
say, because tea contains many of the same
compounds that other HEALING PLANTS do.

North Americans are steeping in news about
the healthful effects of tea, as an
ANTIOXIDANTS and as a possible AID in
REDUCING the risks of STROKE, HEART
DISEASE AND CANCER. But with studies
appearing almost monthly, consumers may
be confused about what scientists have
learned about this beneficial brew. Scientist,
health experts and tea industry officials met in
Washington, D.C., to review the latest
research. In the many papers presented at the
Second International Scientific Symposium on
Tea and Human Health, they reaffirmed what
is already known about tea.

* 1. TEA MAY PROTECT AGAINST several
types of cancer: ORAL, DIGESTIVE, LUNG
AND COLORECTAL CANCERS.

* 2. TEA HAS equal and, in some cases,
GREATER ANTIOXIDANT POWER THAN many
FRUITS AND VEGETABLES.

* 3. TEA MAY REDUCE the risk of STROKE
and HEART DISEASE.

* 4. Although many studies have focused on
green tea, BLACK TEA by far more popular
SEEMS TO HAVE THE SAME POSITIVE
BENEFITS AS GREEN TEA.

Perhaps the most significant of the
symposium's findings was a new study that
showed evidence that TEA CAN PROTECT
AGAINST PRE-CANCEROUS CONDITIONS.
Dr. Junshi Chen of the Chinese Academy of
Preventive Medicine in Beijing studied 59
patients who had been diagnosed with
pre-cancerous oral lesions, white, bumpy
areas on the cheeks or gums. In his study,
Chen had the patients rinse their mouths with
the components found in green and black tea.
He also painted a mixture of tea and glycerin
on the patient's lesions. Chen found that the
treatment both orally and topically inhibited the
growth of pre-cancerous cells. "This is the first
time WE HAVE SEEN TEA PLAY A MAJOR
ROLE IN PROTECTION AGAINST THE
FORMATION OF CANCER in humans," Chen
said in a written statement. The results of the
Chinese study suggest that OTHER epithelial
[SKIN] CANCERS might be SIMILARLY
AFFECTED BY treatment with TEA, says
Jeffrey Blumberg, a senior scientist at the
Jean Mayer U.S.D.A. Human Nutrition
Research Center on Aging at Tufts University
in Boston. "[TEA] actually CAUSED A
REGRESSION," Blumberg says of the
Chinese study. "Obviously the responses
varied, patient to patient. In some, [CANCER]
JUST DISAPPEARED, in some, there was a
marked regression, but it didn't disappear.
"Frankly, I consider this to be good news, but
its not exactly knock your socks off, where did
this come from?" Blumberg says. "You have to
remember that these compounds in TEA are
SIMILAR TO compounds that we find in
FRUITS AND VEGETABLES."

TEA may also play a role in retarding
[SLOWING] the development of LUNG
CANCER, according to studies by a
researcher from the American Health
Foundation of Valhalla, N.Y., a non profit group
that conducts research in preventive medicine.
The researcher, Fung Lung Chung, found that
consuming either black or green TEA retarded
[SLOWED] the development of LUNG
TUMORS in mice and rats.

Another study, conducted on humans by J.E.
Klaunig of the Indiana University School of
Medicine, found that BLACK AND GREEN TEA
REDUCED THE LEVEL OF OXIDATIVE
STRESS [THAT DAMAGES CELLS],
particularly in smokers. Oxidative stress cell
damage associated with environmental
factors such as chemicals, heavy metals and
ultraviolet light. The TEA ingredients
RESPONSIBLE FOR these efforts are
ANTIOXIDANTS called plant polyphenols, a
broad class of plant compounds found in both
green and black tea. Some of the compounds
are unique to tea, but some are SIMILAR TO
antioxidants found in BROCCOLI, SPINACH,
TOMATOES AND OTHER FRUITS AND
VEGETABLES.

Dr. John Weisberger of the American Health
Foundation has said that the quantity of these
plant compounds in TWO CUPS OF TEA is
roughly EQUIVALENT TO what you would find
in ONE SERVING OF FRUITS AND
VEGETABLES. This is not, however, to
suggest that anyone could get by in life just
drinking tea.

The volume of research on tea led to the first
symposium on tea and health in 1991. The
latest gathering, at a U.S. DEPARTMENT OF
AGRICULTURE, was sponsored by the
AMERICAN HEALTH FOUNDATION, the
AMERICAN CANCER SOCIETY, the Nutritional
Committee of the AMERICAN HEART
ASSOCIATION and the TEA COUNCIL OF THE
U.S.A. In Terms of research, there are more
studies on green tea than on black tea. Both
come from the same Camellia sinensis plant,
but each is processed differently. Black tea is
made by exposing the leaves to air, which
turns them reddish brown and gives black tea
its flavor. Green tea, most popular in Japan
and China, involves the least processing. The
green leaves are steamed or heated, and
keep their color. Oolong tea is halfway
between green and black in terms of
processing. HERBAL TEA is a mixture of other
plant leaves, flowers of roots, and can include
fruit or spice flavoring. Its HEALTH EFFECTS
are NOT KNOWN.

BENEFICIAL ANTIOXIDANTS ARE FOUND IN
BOTH GREEN AND BLACK TEA, but in green
tea there are more varieties of the same
molecules, Blumberg says. Some
antioxidants in green tea are converted into
different antioxidants in black tea. But,
Blumberg says, more research is needed.
"Tea is a very complex beverage. Relative to
other issues of nutrition and health, our
understanding of tea is still relatively
elementary."

DRINKING DECAF? Apparently it doesn't
matter whether the tea comes with a buzz.
CAFFEINATED AND DECAFFEINATED TEA
BOTH HAVE BENEFICIAL ANTIOXIDANTS,
says Joe Simrany, president of the Tea
Council of the U.S.A. Tests performed by
Rutgers University researchers found that
decaffeinated tea has most, if not all, of the
active chemicals components that appear to
be acting as antioxidants in tea, Simray says.

Judging FROM the RESEARCH, it appears
that TEA is MUCH BETTER FOR YOU than
some things you could be drinking. "If you are
trying to get on board with eating a healthful
diet, it makes some sense to think about
drinking healthful drinks, not just eating
healthful foods, "Blumberg, says. "When you
think about the healthful attributes of these
fruits and vegetables, here's another food that
has similar characteristics, and doesn't have
the negative attributes, DOESNíT HAVE the
FAT, OR the CHOLESTEROL.

SOURCE:

http://www.cadvision.com/dwornika/insight/tea
.htm
Max
Posted on Thursday, January 04, 2001 - 12:40 am:   Edit PostDelete PostPrint Post   Move Post (Moderator/Admin Only)

Tea Council of the U.S.A. explains: WHATíS IN
TEA THATíS SO GOOOOD FOR YOU

PHYTOCHEMICALS * Naturally occurring
compounds, many of which are thought to play
a role in DECREASING the risk of CANCER
AND HEART DISEASE AND of BOOSTING the
IMMUNE SYSTEM.

Polyphenols * A broad class of antioxidant
phytochemicals found throughout the plant
kingdom.

Flavonoids * A class of polyphenolic
photochemicals that are antioxidants.

Flavonols * A group of FLAVONOIDS found IN
TEA and many fruits and vegetables that ARE
ANTIOXIDANTS. They include rutin, quescetin
and kaempherol.

Cathechins * A group of ANTIOXIDANT
FLAVONOIDS also found IN TEA AND some
FRUITS. Example include epicatechin and
epigallocatechin gallate.

Epigallocatechin Gallate * The principal
cathechin in green and black teas, and a
STRONG ANTIOXIDANT. It has SHOWN TO
REDUCE formation of LUNG TUMORS,
ESOPHAGEAL TUMORS AND SKIN TUMORS.

Theaflavins * Black tea flavonoids produced
from catechins during tea manufacturing and
colored reddish orange. They are STRONG
ANTIOXIDANTS and have PROVED IN
RESEARCH TO REDUCE ESOPHAGEAL
TUMORS AND oxidative DAMAGE TO LUNG
TISSUE.

Thearubigins * Black tea flavonoids, which are
brown and astringent, produced from
carechins during tea manufacturing.

Gallic acid * A POLYPHENOL IN BLACK AND
GREEN TEA WITH ESTABLISHED
ANTIOXIDANT ACTIVITY.

SOURCE:

http://www.cadvision.com/dwornika/insight/tea
.htm
Valm
Posted on Thursday, January 04, 2001 - 7:31 am:   Edit PostDelete PostPrint Post   Move Post (Moderator/Admin Only)

It is soo GOOD to know one of my habits has such redeeming qualities. I am going to brew a pot in a minute!!

Add Your Message Here
Posting is currently disabled in this topic. Contact your discussion moderator for more information.

Topics | Last Day | Last Week | Tree View | Search | Help/Instructions | Program Credits Administration